© Quarterly Homeopathic Digest, Vol. XXVI, 1 & 2/2009. For private circulation only. 3
NOSSAMAN Nicholas (AHZ. 252, 4/2007)
To this day no one knows with certainty what
mechanism is responsible for the healing that takes
place when the similar remedy is prescribed
successfully in Homeopathy. HAHNEMANN
himself acknowledged that: 1. It is unknown, and
2. It is not necessary that it be known for us to have
success in prescribing. Nonetheless, he made his
own proposal for the mechanism involved. In that
spirit of Inquiry this paper explores this topic
further, using the metaphor of mirror. Besides its
applicability in describing the mode of healing
which takes place in Homeopathy, the metaphor is
expanded in relation to successful healing
experiences in general, incorporating concepts
from general systems theory and references to a
wide variety of other fields. Jungian Psychology
and Dream analysis, Native American healing
ceremonies, literature (including the Bible) and
Mythology are all touched upon in the Inquiry. In
addition, the nature and
attributes of the Vital Force, as described by
HAHNEMANN, are discussed.
9. Homöopathie- Eine Frage des Stils
(Homeopathy Ŕ a question of Style)
APPELL Rainer G (AHZ. 252, 4/2007)
Thomas S. KUHN explained anew the term
ŘParadigmř in his work ŖThe Structure of Scientific
Revolutionsŗ. Homeopathy claims to have
overcome the disputes about Paradigm. In the light
of Ludwig FLECKřs work, the concept of mode of
thinking and collective thinking recurs instead.
Like the conventional Medicine Homeopathy has
its own mode of thinking which should be
developed conscientiously. Mutual tolerance is
called for.
10. Conceptions of health, illness and treatment of
patients who use homeopathy in Santos, Brazil.
JUSTO Patriani CM & Gomes Mara H dé
Andrea (HOM. 97, 1/2008)
Objective: To investigate the conceptions of health
and illness, th ereaseons for seeking Homeopathy
and continuing treatment, compliance and the
meaning of the relationship between religiosity and
health for patients who adhere to homeopathy.
Methods: A qualitative study of 20 adult patients in
Santos (Brazil) treated by homeopaths in the public
and private sector for atleast 2 years. Semi-
structured interviews, organized by predefined
thematic categories, the content of the interviews
was analyzed.
Results: The conceptions of health and illness of
the interviewed patients are related to the idea of
vital balance/imbalance mediated by body-mind
interaction. Dissatisfaction with conventional
treatment, family influence and suggestions of
others were the reasons for seeking homeopathic
treatment. Patients continued homeopathic
treatment due to positive therapeutic results, cure
without being aggressive to the organism, the
holistic integrated approach, the preventive nature
of the treatment and low prices of medicine. For
these patients, the availability of Homeopathy in
the public health sector extends the possibility of
access. The need for a wider dissemination of
Homeopathy and the difficulties in following the
prescription are the main problems involved in
continuing treatment. Faith is an important
component. We found a correlation between the
conceptions of health and illness and theprinciples
of Homeopathy, assimilated through a strong bond
between patients and the homeopathic practioners.
Conclusion: To investigate the beliefs, values and
meanings that patients attribute to Homeopathy
helps to understand subjective aspects that may
interfere with treatment compliance.
11. Truth, proof and evidence Homeopathy and the
medical paradigm
SWAYNE Jeremy (HOM. 97, 2/2008)
The study and practice of medicine, in its most
personal and intimate functions, its most
sophisticated scientific and technological
manifestations, and its philosophical and ethical
ramifications, are central to our understanding of
the human condition. Homeopathic medicine: its
insights, the questions that it begs, and the scientific
and philosophical challenges it presents, has a
significant contribution to make to this process.
To be actively and seriously engaged with
Homeopathy is an adventurous undertaking. It is to
be engaged in exploring both human nature and the
nature of the world we inhabit. And in that process
we are also engaged in the pursuit of truth and the
exploration of reality.
This paper deals first with the layout of the
playing field on which Homeopathy has to
compete to be taken seriously. It then discusses
three concepts: reality, truth and knowledge, which
are objectives for which we strive and principles
that guide us in that striving. In the third part it
introduces the concept of Řpersonal knowledgeř as
an essential ingredient of scientific discovery and
the pursuit of truth. And finally it proposes that the
homeopathic community in general, and the Faculty
of Homeopathy in particular, must expand its vision